When she showed up at the movie's April 12 press conference, we were pretty sure that she would get the role of Victoria Gotti in the upcoming Gotti biopic. Well, she's not.

"We are not talking any further about Lindsay playing Victoria," says Marc Fiore, producer of Gotti: Three Generations. "She is no longer being considered. The talks have stopped. We are going to meet with other people [for the role]."

John Travolta who will play the role of Gotti Sr. even said that she was "gorgeous and talented." So is she too expensive? Or is it because of her legal problems that she's been bumped out the project?

"She a wonderful person," Fiore tells PEOPLE. "Her legal case has nothing to do with it. We just couldn't reach terms."